September 11, 2024

Why Are Native Speakers a Selling Point in Language Marketing?

‘Speak like a native’, ‘how to get rid of your accent’, ‘get instant access to native speakers’—these are just a few of the shocking articles, headlines, videos and social media posts I’ve seen while researching this post. 

If you’ve spent more than five minutes in the online language world, it should come as literally no surprise. Schools have been pushing this toxic messaging to boost sales for decades. 

But it’s 2024. You’d think that by now we’d have woken up to the damaging effects of such copy—especially in an industry that’s built on cross-cultural communication.

Yet, the rise of online learning platforms has brought with it a resurgence of native speaker messaging. Instead of using their budgets and influence to reshape the narrative, they too are shamelessly tying the value of their services to the nationality of their teachers.

But… why? Where did this come from? And why are we still clinging to these outdated, unrealistic, and harmful claims?

As a language nerd and messaging strategist I’ve always been curious to find out. So, in this post I’m exploring where the obsession with native speakers came from, why it still persists and what we can do about it. 

Quick disclaimer: it was hard to find much information online, so I’ve pieced together what I could find to try and unpick it. Forgive me (and please let me know) if anything’s inaccurate.

So, where did native speaker marketing come from?

As far as I can tell, the use of native speakerism in language school marketing can be traced back to 1880, when Maximillian Berlitz introduced the immersive learning method. 

Built on the belief that the best way to learn a language is through total immersion, this marked a drastic shift away from the grammar translation method. And a few years later, it became a defining feature of the revolutionary ‘Berlitz Method’. 

But that wasn’t the end of it. 

This new focus on speaking gave rise to two toxic ideas:

  1. That native speakers are the best or ‘most authentic’ tutors
  2. That sounding like a native was the ultimate goal

Soon enough, native speakerism started appearing in Berlitz’s marketing messaging (here’s a slightly disturbing example). Other schools followed suit, and it quickly became the norm in language school marketing, instilling an industry-wide belief that ‘native is best.’

Three types of native speaker marketing

#1 The unrealistic goal

INCLUDES: Speak like a native; achieve native-like fluency; master native pronunciation 

This kind of copy oversimplifies meaningful language learning goals. It promotes the harmful idea that success means eliminating your accent and erasing part of your identity, while putting native speakers on a pedestal. 

It also sets unrealistic standards that leave many students feeling frustrated, insecure and discouraged as they chase an impossible ideal.  

#2 The not-so-unique selling point

INCLUDES: Native-speaking teachers; native-level teachers; access native speakers; learn with native speakers

These phrases show up in both job ads and as selling points on many schools’ websites. They purposely exclude non-native speaking teachers from applying for positions they are qualified for. They then claim this as a reason that their courses are somehow superior. Ironic, considering most of their competitors are saying it too.

#3 The (un)desirable benefits

INCLUDES: Learn to speak to natives; impress native speakers

These phrases may not seem all that bad at first glance. But look again. They suggest that one of the main reasons we might learn a language is to be able to speak to a native.

Don’t get me wrong, being able to speak to people in their first language is rewarding. But that’s not a goal or benefit in and of itself. And it’s not what motivates people to learn.

It’s what the learner wants to gain from those conversations that matters. Freedom? Relationships? Financial stability? It could be anything. Except for speaking to a native for the sake of it.

A response to learner demands… or an excuse?

Many schools and teachers will justify their decision to use these phrases by saying that their students want to learn from or sound like a native speaker. 

They’re not doing anything wrong; they’re just responding to demand. It’s what the people want!

But this is like a personal trainer claiming they help customers reach a size zero. It ignores the client’s actual goal and promotes a damaging idea of success instead.

And that’s on us, not the students. 

Plus, their goals are rarely as superficial as sounding a certain way. 

A woman I interviewed for a recent copywriting project said it best: “I don’t want to sound like a native speaker. I want to sound like me!”

And that’s what most language learners want, isn’t it? To achieve a level of fluency that allows us to fully express ourselves. 

The problem is, before they reach that point, many students may struggle to articulate exactly what they want. So it’s often easier to summarise their goals by saying ‘I want to speak like a native’.

But that doesn’t mean we should take it as read and move on. As school owners, teachers or marketers, it’s our job to find out whether what they actually mean is: 

  • Feeling more settled in another country
  • Getting a new job and a higher salary 
  • Or connecting with people from different places 

Because something is motivating them to invest in the language. And it’s not the dream of sounding like a native. 

What about people who want to learn with native teachers?

While most students don’t actually want to sound like a native speaker, some do say they want to learn from one. So… is it okay to use it as a selling point then? 

No. It’s never okay.

Aside from the fact that this is discriminatory, it doesn’t address students’ motivations for choosing a certain school or teacher.

Because again, there’s almost always a deeper reason they’re searching for a specific type of person. 

Take my client’s students, for example. They’re actively seeking to learn with British teachers because they used to live or study in the UK. Now, they want to emulate the same experience they had there without needing to travel. 

Whether or not they would learn with a non-native English teacher is their choice. But it’s the school’s job to focus on the students’ connection to the UK. Not the nationality of its teachers. 

This doesn’t only help the student make a more informed decision on who to learn with. It also shows how well the school understands them. And that’s the key to good marketing.

So, why are companies still pushing this message?

Honestly? Because it’s easy.

Writing specific, empowering copy takes time, effort and in-depth market research, which most people aren’t willing to do. It’s way quicker to summarise varied and nuanced goals with this catchy one-liner. And if no one’s complaining, why change it?

But that’s exactly the problem.

If no one is bold enough to try something new, nothing will change. Companies will continue putting native speakers on a pedestal, students will still be encouraged to pursue an unhealthy ideal, and teachers who don’t fit the ‘native speaker’ criteria will keep losing out.

Every time we sit down to write copy, we have a choice to do better. A chance to do our bit in creating a new narrative that acknowledges our students’ goals and celebrates our teachers.

After all, if marketing was powerful enough to create this belief, it’s surely powerful enough to dismantle it. Right?

A friendly note 

Are you using native speaker messaging in your marketing? If so, this isn’t an attack! I think the narrative has become so ingrained that many people are using it without realising the harmful effects. 

If you’d like some advice on what to do instead, feel free to drop me an email. I believe the only way we can start to change it is by exploring the alternatives—together.

If you're enjoying the blog, you'll love my newsletter. Sign up to receive free weekly marketing and copywriting tip in to your inbox. 

Get free weekly marketing tips